Holding the Fold Open: An Energy and Stability Model of Borg Transwarp Conduit Apertures, Built from Sensor Records to 2378
Abstract
The sustained-fold approach treats a transwarp conduit as a fold in subspace that must be held open at both ends, and we apply it to the sensor records of Borg conduit apertures and of the transwarp hub destroyed in 2378. We write in 2379, after those records were deposited. From twelve apertures observed at standoff away from the hub (radii 210 to 860 m) we fitted the holding power against aperture radius on the logarithmic scale. The exponent was 1.87 (95% CI 1.66 to 2.08), close to the value of 2 expected if the cost is set by the area of the opening, and at 2 the cost is about 25 GW for each square metre of aperture. For nine apertures resolved at the hub, held out of the fit, the model gave 49 PW against a thermal inference of 44 PW (stated range 29 to 66). In seven far-end apertures that closed after the hub lost power, closure time rose in proportion to radius, with a wall speed of about 1.15 million metres per second. We conclude that a conduit is likely to end only where an anchor supplies the holding power, and that unanchored transwarp flight is likely to demand the same power continuously. The model says nothing about how the anchors generate that power.
1. Introduction
The sustained-fold approach to transwarp conduits was set out in Daystrom studies of the early 2370s, which treated a conduit as a fold in subspace that stays open only while something keeps it open (Benedetti-Ng, 2373). We apply it to the sensor records of Borg conduit apertures. The aim of this note is to set out a model that prices an aperture by its size, accounts for the stability of the conduit and (the point Federation engineers have found hardest) explains why conduits end only at fixed exits in normal space.
We write in 2379, and we use two bodies of record. The first is a series of standoff observations of conduit apertures made by Federation vessels and by USS Voyager between 2370 and 2378 (Starfleet Fleet Telemetry Archive, 2378). The second is the sensor record of the transwarp hub (a nexus at which many conduits meet) that was destroyed in 2378 during USS Voyager's return to the Alpha Quadrant, at the time the neurolytic pathogen spread through the Collective. The price of the approach is stated at once: both bodies describe a single network, seen from outside, and the network no longer exists.
Three questions are put to the record.
What does it cost, in power, to hold an aperture of a given size open? Why does a conduit terminate at a fixed exit? And what does the model imply for the Federation's own attempts at open transwarp flight, which did not succeed where the Borg conduit network, so far as the record shows, did?
2. System Description
In the model a conduit is a tube of folded subspace joining an entry aperture to an exit aperture, and each aperture is held open by a structure (an anchor) at its own end. We treat the anchor as a black box that supplies power to the fold wall (its design is not our subject), and we make no claim about how it does so. The hub is the anchor for the entry apertures of the conduits that meet there. We assume that each anchor dissipates its own holding power (so that the hub's thermal output includes only the apertures at the hub), but that the far-end anchors depend on the network the hub served, and that when the hub was destroyed in 2378 they ceased to supply power. The far-end closures of Section 4 are read on that assumption, and the hub test of Section 4 depends on its first half. Aperture size is given throughout as a radius, a, in metres, and a result quoted for radius would change in its constant, though not in its exponent, if restated for diameter.
Radius was taken from the imaging series, calibrated against standoff measurements of the subspace emission at the rim of each aperture (Hasselgren, 2374). Holding power, P, in petawatts (PW), was inferred from that emission at standoff. Twelve apertures were observed at a distance from the hub, with radii from 210 to 860 m, and these form the fitting sample. In four of the twelve a vessel was in transit during the observation. The remaining records are of nine apertures resolved around the hub in the final hours of its existence, with radii from 300 to 620 m. None of the twelve fitting apertures is among these nine or among the seven far-end apertures below, so the three groups hold 28 distinct apertures. We did not use the hub apertures in the fit, and the count of nine is the number the sensors resolved, not a claim that it was all of them.
Two further quantities come from the hub record. A thermal output of 44 PW, with a stated range of 29 to 66 PW, was inferred for the hub from the radiated heat observed at standoff, on the assumption that the holding power is dissipated entirely as heat (Teodorescu-Lyle, 2371). Separately, seven apertures at the far ends of conduits were seen to close after the hub lost power, and their closure times were read from the sensor logs, with radii of 240 to 700 m. The earliest observation in the series dates from 2370, and we rest nothing on its detail.
3. Analysis and Model
Holding power needs one exponent and one constant, and closure one further constant, the wall speed.
The model rests on one physical idea. A fold wall leaks inward at a rate set by its own tension, and therefore the power needed to hold the opening is the power needed to replace what leaks, and the leak occurs across the opening. Holding power should then scale with the area of the aperture: P = κa2, where κ is the power per unit area of aperture. A cost set by the rim would scale as a and one set by a volume of enclosed field as a3. In plain terms: double the radius of an aperture and the power needed to hold it open should rise fourfold.
We fitted the logarithm of P to the logarithm of a by ordinary least squares on the twelve fitting apertures, and we used the t distribution with 10 degrees of freedom for the interval, because the sample is small. The exponent was 1.87 (95% CI 1.66 to 2.08, Table 1). The data thus reject an exponent of 1 (a rim-limited cost) and of 3 (a volume-limited cost), whereas they do not reject 2. The fit explained 97.5% of the variance of log power, and the residual standard deviation on the log scale was 0.14, or about 14% in power.
With the exponent fixed at 2 we obtained κ = 2.54 × 10−5 PW per square metre (95% CI 2.3 to 2.8 × 10−5), which is about 25 GW for each square metre of aperture. Take, say, an aperture of 400 m radius, for which the model gives 4.1 PW to hold it open. A conduit has two apertures, and in this model the length of the conduit adds nothing we can detect, since the apertures in the sample belong to conduits of very different lengths (the record gives the length of too few of them for the point to be tested), and we therefore leave length out of the model.
The second part of the model concerns the end of the conduit, where the fold must satisfy a boundary condition that only a powered end can meet (Varnholt, 2368). An anchored aperture receives its holding power and stays open. An aperture with no anchor receives none, and its wall relaxes inward at a speed v, and thus the aperture closes in a time τ = a/v. A conduit cannot then end at an arbitrary point, because a free end closes before anything can pass through it: the exit has to be a place where an anchor already stands. That a conduit must end at an anchor follows from the premises of the model and is not a finding. What the record can decide is whether unpowered apertures close in a time proportional to their radius, which Section 4 tests. The model is silent on how the anchors came to be placed. Accordingly, it cannot say whether the apparent regularity of the network reflects a plan or a history.
4. Validation Against Field Data
The exponent could have been produced by the traffic through an aperture and not by its size, since a vessel passing through an aperture may draw power from the fold. We tested this by adding an indicator for a vessel in transit to the regression (three parameters, 9 degrees of freedom). The indicator corresponded to a factor of 1.02 on power (95% CI 0.83 to 1.24), and the exponent stayed at 1.87 (95% CI 1.64 to 2.09). Traffic is the more plausible of the alternatives to the area relation, and the data do not exclude a modest effect of it (the interval allows a factor of up to 1.24). We nevertheless think it the less likely explanation of the exponent, because the four apertures observed in transit sit on the same line as the other eight and the interval for the indicator is centred on no effect.
An out-of-sample test is available at the hub. We applied the area law with the fitted constant (P = κa2, exponent fixed at 2) to the nine resolved hub apertures (Table 3) and summed the results. The sum was 49 PW, with a 95% interval of 43 to 57 PW that allows for the uncertainty of κ and for the residual scatter of nine independent apertures (t distribution with 11 degrees of freedom). The thermal inference for the hub was 44 PW (range 29 to 66), a ratio of 0.89 to the model. The thermal figure lies within the interval of the model, and the model value lies well within the stated range of the thermal figure. However, agreement of this kind counts for something and still falls short of proof, since the thermal range is wide, and moreover the thermal figure rests on its own assumption about dissipation.
Closure times came from the seven far-end apertures, whose anchors (on the assumption of Section 2) ceased to supply power when the hub was lost. Their times rose with radius on the logarithmic scale with a slope of 0.97 (95% CI 0.69 to 1.25, t distribution with 5 degrees of freedom), as τ = a/v requires. The wall speed was 1.15 × 106 metres per second (95% CI 1.06 to 1.26 × 106), which is about 0.4% of the speed of light. At the 400 m radius used above, the closure time is 0.35 ms.
These results bear on the Federation's attempts. Every transit in the record lasted far longer than a millisecond (the shortest logged transit lasted several seconds), and a free end cannot carry traffic when it closes in a fraction of one. An open-flight vessel would be in the position of the free end. The USS Excelsior trials of 2285 produced a drive that, so far as the Corps of Engineers report allows us to say, did not enter service (the later history is not settled in the records we hold), and the report gives no aperture data that we could use (Starfleet Corps of Engineers Reports, 2285). The failure of the one attempt on record is attributed in the report to interference with the drive, not from its physics, and it is therefore no evidence for or against the model. The quantum slipstream trials of 2374 and 2375 are recorded in the ship's engineering ledger as unsuccessful, the later of them through phase variance (Starfleet Delta Quadrant Mission Records, 2378), and the warp 10 crossing of 2372 is a single anomalous event that we exclude. For a vessel opening a fold of 150 m aperture radius, a size we assume for illustration, the model gives a closure time of 0.13 ms and a continuous holding power of 0.57 PW at each end. However, 150 m lies below our fitted range, and the figures are an extrapolation. A sustained fold of this size, with nothing at the far end to hold it, is likely to close long before any vessel completes a passage (Pellegrin-Voss, 2373).
5. Failure Modes
The model has limits that the record exposes, and we set out those that we can identify.
Unfortunately, the sample is small, and it was not drawn by design. The twelve apertures are those that vessels happened to observe at standoff, and bright, large apertures are easier to image than faint, small ones, and hence the range of radii is probably narrower than that of the network, and the exponent could shift if faint apertures were included. The use of the t distribution widens the intervals as it should, whereas it does not repair a biased sample, and consequently the exponent is secure only for apertures of the sizes that vessels were able to image.
The hub comparison depends on an assumption in the thermal inference. If only part of the holding power left the hub as heat, the inferred output would be larger by the inverse of that fraction, and at two thirds it would reach 66 PW, some 34% above the model sum. We do not know the fraction, and hence the agreement should be read with that uncertainty in mind. The nine hub apertures are not known to be the whole set either, and a larger set would raise the model sum in proportion.
Closure times were measured at the moment the network collapsed, and the closure of a far-end aperture could have been driven by the collapse of the whole network as well as by the relaxation of its own wall. If instead the far-end anchors drew power through the conduit from the hub itself, the hub would have dissipated the holding power of both ends, the model sum for the hub would roughly double, and the agreement of Section 4 would fail. We therefore cannot treat the closure test and the hub test as independent support. If the network collapse drove the closures, the wall speed we report is a measure of the network failing, and the proportionality to radius is perhaps an accident of seven points. We cannot separate the two with the record we have, and the closure times may include delays in the sensor logs of the same order as the times themselves.
A phase-variance account of the slipstream failures is given in the ledger as a different explanation of why open flight failed, and our model neither confirms nor excludes it. The accounts are not exclusive, and a fold that closes in a fraction of a millisecond could also be one whose phase drifts, and we cannot tell which came first. The model also says nothing about the anchor, including whatever generates its power, since it tests only what the apertures demand.
6. Conclusion
Within this record, the power needed to hold a Borg conduit aperture open is likely to rise with the area of the aperture, a conduit is likely to end only where an anchor supplies that power, and open transwarp flight is therefore likely to demand the same continuous power with no anchor to share it. The model is offered as the simplest one we found that reproduces the measured scaling and, given the dissipation assumption of Section 2, the thermal output of the hub, and it is not offered as the account of Borg technology. One plausible alternative, that traffic through an aperture sets its power, may still account for part of the scatter, but the transit indicator was centred on no effect (a factor of 1.02, 95% CI 0.83 to 1.24), and we therefore judge the area relation the likelier, although a larger sample could change the exponent.
How far the result reaches depends on how far the method reaches, and that is not far, the record being twelve apertures, seven closures and one thermal inference, all from a single network now destroyed. The decisive record would be one in which two or more vessels log a single aperture from formation to closure, since the model fixes in advance the numbers (an exponent near 2 and a closure time proportional to radius) that such a record would confirm or contradict.
References
- Benedetti-Ng, A. (2373). Sustained folds in subspace as a model of transwarp transit, and the power needed to keep them open. Subspace Engineering Quarterly, 19(2), 140–166.
- Starfleet Fleet Telemetry Archive (2378). Standoff imaging and emission records of Borg transwarp conduit apertures, and sensor record of the transwarp hub, 2370–2378. Starfleet Fleet Telemetry Archive, accession FT-2644.
- Starfleet Delta Quadrant Mission Records (2378). Engineering ledger of USS Voyager (NCC-74656), quantum slipstream trial entries, 2374–2375. Starfleet Delta Quadrant Mission Records, NCC-74656, engineering ledger series.
- Starfleet Corps of Engineers (2285). Preliminary report on the transwarp drive trials aboard USS Excelsior. Starfleet Corps of Engineers Reports, SCE-85-031.
- Hasselgren, K. (2374). Standoff sensing of subspace emission and the calibration of aperture radius. Journal of Applied Field Dynamics, 14(1), 33–58.
- Teodorescu-Lyle, M. (2371). Thermal inference of dissipated power from large field-generating structures. Subspace Engineering Quarterly, 17(3), 201–224.
- Varnholt, E. (2368). Boundary conditions at the ends of sustained subspace folds. Journal of Applied Field Dynamics, 8(1), 91–118.
- Pellegrin-Voss, A. (2373). Collapse dynamics of unanchored field boundaries in engine test rigs. Utopia Planitia Fleet Yards Technical Notes, 17(1), 12–35.
Open in Uncited Press →