Testimony Out of Time: The Structure of Orb-Experience Accounts in the Vedek Assembly Register, 2369–2376, and the Theology of the Dark Interval
Abstract
The Orbs, which Bajorans call the Tears of the Prophets, give those who approach them visions that Bajoran faith receives as encounters with the Prophets, the advanced non-corporeal beings who dwell in the Bajoran wormhole. Accounts of these experiences have been gathered by the Vedek Assembly since the end of the Occupation, but they have been read one at a time, as individual revelations. We read them as a body. Our corpus is the Assembly's register of testimony from 2369 to 2376, 412 accounts given by those who approached an Orb under a vedek's guidance. We argue three things. First, Orb testimony is a genre with a stable form: the witness meets figures from their own life, finds events out of their order, and returns with a question more often than an instruction. Second, that form fits what is otherwise known of the Prophets, who stand outside linear time, and Bajoran theology has made this central. Third, the months of 2374–2375 when the wormhole closed and the Orbs went dark changed the genre. Testimony from after the restoration carries a motif of absence and return that was rare before, and Bajoran teaching now reads the dark interval as a lesson in faith without sight, ended by the Emissary. We close by weighing psychological and political readings of the experiences.
1. Introduction
For Bajorans, the Orbs are the Tears of the Prophets: objects of great power sent from the Celestial Temple to guide the people. Nine appeared over some ten thousand years of Bajoran history, and in 2375 a tenth, the Orb of the Emissary, was recovered. Those who approach an Orb under proper guidance may receive an Orb experience, a vision that the faithful understand as a meeting with the Prophets. The Prophets are advanced non-corporeal beings who dwell within the Bajoran wormhole, the Celestial Temple of Bajoran belief. What they intend by the visions is a question for Bajoran theology, and we treat it as such.
Accounts of Orb experiences have always circulated. Since the end of the Cardassian Occupation in 2369, the Vedek Assembly has gathered them in a register, recording each witness's account soon after the experience (Vedek Assembly, 2377). The register has been used as a resource for devotion and for the Assembly's own discernment, which reads each account as a particular revelation to a particular person. This essay reads the accounts together, as testimony with a shared form, and asks what that form shows about the experience and about the faith that receives it. We write in 2377, when the register's first volumes were published.
2. Corpus and Approach
During the Occupation the Cardassians took every Orb but one, which was kept hidden by the Kai. In the register's first years that single Orb was the only one in Bajoran hands, and an Orb experience was a rare privilege granted by the Assembly. Other Orbs were returned in the years that followed. The register holds 412 accounts from 2369 to 2376, given by witnesses who approached an Orb under a vedek's guidance at a shrine on Bajor or at the station Deep Space 9. The accounts are recorded in the witness's own words and are published with the witness's consent; a further 57 were withheld at the witness's request and are not included.
We read every account and coded each for the elements it contained: who the witness met, whether the vision concerned past, present or future, whether events appeared out of their order, and how the vision ended. The coding was ours, and it is interpretive; we give counts to show a pattern, not as measurement. Our reading is informed by the Assembly's own commentaries on the accounts (Vedek Assembly, 2377) and by earlier Bajoran writing on the Orbs, much of it lost before or during the Occupation and known from later copies (Tessandre, 2358).
3. A Genre of Testimony
Orb testimony has a recognisable shape. In most accounts the witness finds themselves in a place from their own life and meets people they know, often the dead or the absent, who speak to them with knowledge the witness does not expect them to have. In 327 of the 412 accounts (79%) the witness met at least one person from their own life. Strangers, landscapes without people and abstract visions do occur, but they are the minority.
Events in these visions do not keep their order. Witnesses describe conversations that begin with an answer, deaths that come before the illness, childhoods revisited with knowledge of what followed. In 271 accounts (66%) there is at least one such displacement. Witnesses rarely describe it as confusion. They describe it as a feature of the place they were in, as if the order they were used to belonged to them and not to it.
Most characteristic of all is the ending. Only 38 accounts (9%) report an instruction. Far more, 249 (60%), end with a question, returned to the witness by one of the figures, which the witness carries out of the experience and must answer in life. The Assembly's own teaching on Orb guidance holds that the Prophets do not command but teach (Vedek Assembly, 2371; Wexcombe, 2374), and the register's endings fit that teaching: questions outnumber instructions more than six to one.
4. Beings Outside Sequence
The displacement of time in Orb testimony matches what is otherwise known of the Prophets. Starfleet's first direct contact with the wormhole's inhabitants, in 2369, found beings to whom linear time was unfamiliar, who had to be shown what it meant for one moment to follow another (Starfleet Command, 2369). Visions sent, or shaped, by such beings would be expected to carry their own relation to time, not ours.
Bajoran theology has drawn on this in its own terms. For the faithful, the Prophets' indifference to sequence is part of their holiness: they see a life whole, and they speak to it from that wholeness. The question returned at the end of an Orb experience is, on this reading, a question the Prophets can ask because they already stand where its answer lies. Vedeks who guide witnesses teach them to expect this and not to demand of the vision the order of a story (Nakagawa-Rolle, 2375).
5. The Dark Interval
Late in 2374 a Pah-wraith, one of the beings Bajoran belief holds to be the Prophets' ancient adversaries, was released into the Orb held at Deep Space 9. The wormhole collapsed, and every Orb went dark. For months no Orb experience could be had, and the register for that period records only accounts of vigils at dark Orbs, which we have not counted. Bajoran commentary from the period reads the closing as a withdrawal of the Prophets, and some commentators read it as a judgment. In 2375 the Emissary, the Starfleet officer whom Bajoran faith recognises as the Prophets' chosen, recovered and opened the Orb of the Emissary; the Pah-wraiths were driven out, the wormhole reopened and the Orbs were restored.
Testimony after the restoration differs from what came before. Of the 64 accounts recorded after the restoration and before the end of 2376, 25 (39%) contain a motif of absence and return: a figure who leaves and comes back, a door closed and then opened, a voice silent and then heard. Among the 348 accounts from before the closing, the motif appears in 9 (2.6%). We do not claim that the Prophets changed what they showed. It may be that witnesses, having lived through the dark months, now noticed and reported what they had not before. Either way the genre changed, and the Assembly's teaching changed with it. Bajoran homilies since 2375 treat the dark interval as a lesson in faith without sight, a time when devotion continued without any vision to sustain it, ended not by the faithful but by the Emissary's act (Vedek Assembly, 2376).
Accounts were fewer after the restoration, about forty a year against more than sixty before, although more Orbs were then in Bajoran hands. The Assembly restricted access during the last months of the war and in the wake of the Pah-wraith's release, and some of the faithful hesitated to approach an Orb at all.
6. Counter-readings
A psychological reading holds that Orb experiences are the witness's own mind, stimulated by the Orb's energies, working through its own memories and questions (Castellano, 2373). The prominence of familiar figures and the returned question fit this reading well. It explains less easily the displacement of time, which witnesses describe as foreign to their own thinking, and it does not explain why the experiences stopped when the wormhole closed and resumed when the Pah-wraiths were driven out, which ties them to the wormhole's inhabitants. A reading can grant that the witness's mind shapes the vision without denying that something outside it provides the occasion.
On a political reading, the register, compiled by the Vedek Assembly, selects and presents accounts so as to support the Assembly's authority. The Assembly's control of access to the Orbs, and its role in recording testimony, give this reading force, and the 57 withheld accounts are a real gap (Serrell-Obi, 2376). Yet the register includes many accounts that sit uneasily with the Assembly's teaching, including accounts critical of vedeks, and the genre's features appear in accounts from witnesses outside the faith, including non-Bajorans who approached an Orb at the station. A selective register would have been tidier.
7. Conclusion
Orb testimony is a genre, and its form follows from the nature of what is encountered: beings who stand outside sequence, whose visions arrive out of order and end in questions. The dark interval of 2374–2375 showed that the genre can change, and the change has become part of Bajoran faith. For the comparative study of religion, the register offers a rare case: a body of testimony, recorded as it happened, that the faithful receive as revelation, tied to beings whose existence is not in dispute even though their meaning remains a matter of faith.
References
- Vedek Assembly (2377). Register of Orb experiences with commentaries, 2369–2376. Vedek Assembly Record, volumes 1–4.
- Vedek Assembly (2371). Teachings on the guidance of those who approach the Orbs. Vedek Assembly Record, instruction 12.
- Vedek Assembly (2376). Homilies on the dark interval, collected. Vedek Assembly Record, homiletic series 3.
- Tessandre, M. (2358). Pre-Occupation writings on the Orbs, a survey of surviving copies. Alpha Centauri Review of Religious Studies, 72(1), 41–77.
- Wexcombe, T. (2374). Teaching without commanding, the returned question in Bajoran devotion. Alpha Centauri Review of Religious Studies, 88(2), 115–140.
- Nakagawa-Rolle, H. (2375). Holiness outside sequence, time in Bajoran theology of the Prophets. Alpha Centauri Review of Religious Studies, 89(1), 3–35.
- Castellano, I. (2373). Memory and expectation in reported Orb experiences, a psychological reading. Starfleet Medical Journal, 96(3), 255–270.
- Serrell-Obi, P. (2376). Who keeps the testimony, the Vedek Assembly and the politics of the register. Alpha Centauri Review of Religious Studies, 90(2), 144–171.
- Starfleet Command (2369). First contact with the inhabitants of the Bajoran wormhole, commanding officer's report. Starfleet Contact Records, SCR-69-002.
Open in Uncited Press →