Who Could Have Heard the Coordinate Broadcast? Strain at Trisolaris and Beyond, and the Receiver Sensitivity That a Striking Civilisation Must Have Had
Abstract
We study the receiver sensitivity that a civilisation must have had in order to strike Trisolaris after the gravitational-wave coordinate broadcast, using the far-field strain of a monochromatic source and the geometry of the delay between broadcast and strike. No source available to this paper gives the interval between broadcast and strike, the position of the broadcasting ships, the duration of the emission, or the power or frequency of the antenna, and each is therefore a parameter of the model. For an isotropic tone of 100 Hz and 1015 W, with ships 3 light-years from Trisolaris, the strain at Trisolaris is 7.9 × 10-30. A strike at 5 years after the broadcast by a weapon at 0.99 of light speed places the listener no farther than 3.99 light-years from the ships, so the listener received a strain of at least 5.9 × 10-30. That fact alone caps the sensitivity required. A lower bound on the listener's technology needs a minimum distance, which no source supplies, and we adopt 1 light-year as a scenario. On that assumption the listener's amplitude noise floor, for a 12 h emission integrated in full and a signal-to-noise ratio of 8, was likely no worse than 6.2 × 10-28 per root hertz, about four orders of magnitude below a laboratory reference of our own choosing. The ratio of the greatest to the least admissible distance, 4.0 here, is independent of power and frequency, and the absolute floor is not.
1. Introduction
In the model of this paper, a gravitational-wave tone of 100 Hz radiated isotropically at 1015 W from a point 3 light-years from Trisolaris arrives there with a strain amplitude of 7.9 × 10-30. At 3.99 light-years from the emitter, the farthest a listener could have stood and still struck within 5 years of the broadcast, the amplitude is 5.9 × 10-30, and at 1 light-year it is 2.4 × 10-29.
We study the receiver that such a listener must have owned using the far-field strain of a monochromatic source and the arithmetic of the delay between broadcast and strike. The broadcast is the single coordinate transmission sent by Gravity and Blue Space in deep space, and the strike is the photoid attack that destroyed Trisolaris several years later (Ketteridge, 7 BkE). We write in Bunker Era, Year 9 (BkE 9), and every source we use was closed before that year.
Five quantities that the argument needs are not given by any source available to us. These are the interval between broadcast and strike, the position of the ships, the duration of the emission, the power of the antenna and its frequency. The chronology we cite dates both events only to the era-year, so that the interval between them is open to about a year at best and no value of it is fixed. We treat each quantity as a parameter, we evaluate the results over a stated range, and every value in the paper is the model's own and not a statement about the event. Two assumptions have different jobs. The first is that the striking civilisation learned the position of Trisolaris from the broadcast and acted on hearing it. The latency then bounds the listener's distance from above, so the strain it received was at least the strain at that greatest distance, and this gives a ceiling on the sensitivity the listener needed, because a nearer listener needed less. The second assumption is a minimum distance between the listener and the ships, and it, not the latency, carries the headline bound on the listener's technology.
We take the emission to be a single tone lasting a time τ, with 12 h as the headline value of our own choosing and a range from 1 h to one year. No figure for the duration comes from any record.
2. Methods
A source radiating gravitational-wave power P at a single frequency f, equally in all directions, delivers at distance r a flux F = P / 4πr². For a plane wave of one polarisation and amplitude h this flux is F = c³ω²h² / 32πG, with ω = 2πf, so that the amplitude is h(r) = (2πf r)-1 (8GP / c³)1/2. The strain therefore falls as 1/r and scales as the square root of the power divided by the frequency, a dependence which governs every figure below (Dlamini-Reyes, 57 DE). We took G = 6.6743 × 10-11 m³ kg-1 s-2 and c = 299,792,458 m/s and every figure comes from a script that uses no random numbers. Nothing is fitted.
The geometry follows from the delay. Let the broadcast leave the ships at time zero, let the ships lie at distance D from Trisolaris, and let a listener stand at distance r from the ships and s from Trisolaris. The listener hears the broadcast at r/c, launches at once, and sends a weapon that travels at βc, so a strike on Trisolaris at time T requires T ≥ r/c + s/βc. Since s cannot be shorter than |r − D|, the farthest admissible listener lies on the line through the ships and Trisolaris, beyond Trisolaris, at a distance r − D from it, and its distance from the ships is r<sub>max</sub> = (βcT + D) / (1 + β) for T ≥ D/c. We restrict T to T ≥ D/c, since an earlier strike is impossible for a weapon slower than light launched on hearing the broadcast.
Any reaction or preparation time lowers r<sub>max</sub>, so that the figure is an upper limit on distance and the strain at that distance is a lower limit on what the listener received.
Detection fixes the sensitivity. For a steady tone of amplitude h<sub>0</sub> observed for a time τ against noise of one-sided spectral density S<sub>n</sub>, the matched-filter signal-to-noise ratio is ρ = h<sub>0</sub> (τ / S<sub>n</sub>)1/2, and a threshold of ρ = 8 is adopted for a tone of known frequency in stationary noise (Maruyama-Osei, 49 DE). The listener's amplitude spectral density at the tone frequency, in strain per root hertz, must then satisfy S<sub>n</sub>1/2 ≤ h<sub>0</sub> (τ)1/2 / 8. The listener integrates over the whole emission, so that τ is the emission duration, and a longer integration would add only noise. It cannot launch before the integration ends, which makes τ a reaction time; at 12 h this shortens r<sub>max</sub> by less than 0.001 light-years and we ignore it, and at one year it is the 1-year case of Section 3, with r<sub>max</sub> of 3.50. We took τ = 12 h, and we compare the result with a reference floor of 10-23 per root hertz, a round figure of our own for a laboratory-scale receiver.
The ranges are as follows. Power runs from 1012 to 1018 W, frequency from 10 to 1,000 Hz, latency from 3.5 to 10 years, weapon speed from 0.9 to 0.999 of c, emission duration from 1 h to one year, and ship distance from Trisolaris takes the values 3 and 5 light-years. Trisolaris lies about 4 light-years from the Sun, so D = 3 and D = 5 each need only that the ships stood at least 1 light-year from the Sun, on a suitable heading. The headline case is 1015 W, 100 Hz, T = 5 years, β = 0.99 and D = 3 light-years. The minimum distance is a scenario variable with values from 0.3 to 2 light-years, headline 1.
A sophon can alter a logged outcome at a detector at every epoch after the Crisis began, including the Broadcast and Bunker Eras. Our argument uses no detector log. Grounding the minimum distance in archival searches for technosignatures would inherit the caveat, and would hold only against an adversary that left those records untouched.
3. Results
For the headline source, Table 1 gives the strain at increasing distance and the amplitude spectral density that a receiver needs in order to recover the tone at ρ = 8 in 12 h. Trisolaris, at 3 light-years, receives 7.9 × 10-30. The required floor falls with the strain, from 1.2 × 10-27 at 0.5 light-years to 6.2 × 10-30 per root hertz at 100 light-years.
Distance bounds follow in Table 2. At T = 5 years and β = 0.99 with the ships 3 light-years from Trisolaris, r<sub>max</sub> is 3.99 light-years. It barely depends on the weapon speed once that speed is near light speed, for it is 3.95 at β = 0.9 and 4.00 at 0.999, and it depends instead on the ship distance and on the latency, to which it responds at about 0.5 light-years for each year added. Moving the ships to 5 light-years admits no strike before 5 years and gives 5.50 at 6 years.
Reaction time matters more than weapon speed. With T = 5 years and D = 3 light-years, a listener which needed 1 year to prepare could stand no farther than 3.50 light-years, and one that needed 2 years only Trisolaris itself, at 3.00. Beyond 2 years no listener is admissible at all, so T − D, here 2 years, is the largest total time that the listener can have spent between hearing and launching.
Strain at the listener was therefore at least 5.9 × 10-30 in the headline case, and a receiver with an amplitude floor of 1.5 × 10-28 per root hertz would have recovered the tone at ρ = 8 anywhere inside r<sub>max</sub>. That ceiling lies 4.8 orders of magnitude below the reference floor, which makes it the weakest demand that the latency alone can place on the listener.
A floor becomes a bound on technology only when a minimum distance is supplied, and Table 3 gives it for four scenarios. At a minimum of 1 light-year, the headline, the listener's floor was likely no worse than 6.2 × 10-28 per root hertz, which is 4.2 orders of magnitude below the reference. The ratio of the greatest to the least admissible distance sets the width of the window between ceiling and floor, and it is 13.3, 8.0, 4.0 and 2.0 for minima of 0.3, 0.5, 1 and 2 light-years.
Power and frequency move the absolute scale and leave the ratio alone. The floor in Table 3 scales as P1/2/f. At the headline minimum of 1 light-year it is 1.9 × 10-30 per root hertz at 1012 W and 1,000 Hz and 1.9 × 10-25 at 1018 W and 10 Hz, five orders of magnitude, with the headline near the middle. The minimum distance moves it far less, by a factor of 6.7 from 0.3 to 2 light-years, or 0.8 orders. The emission duration enters as a square root, so that the floor is 1.8 × 10-28 per root hertz for 1 h and 1.7 × 10-26 for a year, or 2.0 orders, which is 2.8 orders below the reference, with the ceiling then set by a r<sub>max</sub> of 3.50 light-years.
4. Discussion
Our finding is that a civilisation which struck Trisolaris on hearing the broadcast likely owned a receiver with a noise floor no worse than a few parts in 1028 per root hertz at the tone frequency, for the source we modelled, and that the bound exists only because of the minimum distance to which we committed, while its absolute value is set mostly by the assumed power and frequency, which move it over five orders of magnitude against less than one for the minimum distance. The latency alone gives a weaker statement, a ceiling on what the listener needed, and only the floor is a statement about the listener's technology.
An alternative explanation is that the listener never needed the broadcast. A civilisation which had already located Trisolaris by other means, and which struck on its own schedule, may have a strike time unrelated to the broadcast, and the distance bound would not apply to it. We think this less likely, though not impossible, since a listener with prior knowledge and a weapon in hand has no evident reason to have waited for the broadcast. We cannot exclude the coincidence from the delay alone, which is the reason the bound is conditional.
Earlier discussion of the strike treated the question as one of motive and left receivers aside (Ketteridge, 7 BkE). The strain of a distant emitter was known (Dlamini-Reyes, 57 DE), but without the delay as a bound on position it could not be turned into a statement about a listener. The framework in this paper supplies that link, and the result is a window of sensitivities with its ends labelled by the assumptions that set them.
We work within the Lurker framework, for which the Luo-Ji / Ye axioms hold in the local domain only (Halvorsen-Adeyemi, 7 BkE). A listener that struck is therefore not, for us, the application of a rule that reaches every domain, and we draw no inference about its motive. Nothing in Sections 2 and 3 depends on that position, since the strains and distances follow from the parameters alone, whatever the school of the reader.
The concealment literature adds a caution to the minimum distance. A civilisation which keeps silent in the sense of that literature also listens, and its receivers are not advertised (Orlova-Banda, 8 BkE). The absence of any reported technosignature near the ships is thus likely weak evidence that no listener stood close, and for that reason we present the minimum distance as a scenario and not as a measurement.
5. Limitations
In the model the source is an isotropic tone, while the real antenna may have been beamed or broadband. A beamed antenna of gain g raises the strain on its axis by the square root of g and lowers it elsewhere, so the bound moves in either direction with the listener's bearing. A listener on the axis received more than our figures and needed a less demanding floor, and one off axis received less and needed a more demanding one. The isotropic source is the neutral case.
The geometry assumes a listener that launched at once and a weapon at constant speed on a straight path. Acceleration, reaction time and any lowered-speed region lengthen the delay and shorten r<sub>max</sub> (Pieterse-Lund, 8 BkE). The ceiling of Table 1 is therefore the most demanding reading the latency allows. Any delay we left out shortens r<sub>max</sub>, raises the least strain at the listener and relaxes the ceiling, and leaves the floor unchanged while r<sub>max</sub> stays above the minimum distance. A delay that brings r<sub>max</sub> below it makes the scenario inadmissible.
Our reference floor of 10-23 per root hertz, the threshold of 8 and the 12 h emission are conventions of the paper. The floor scales as the square root of the duration (Section 3), which no source gives.
Latency, ship position, emission duration, power and frequency are not known to us, and the paper does not constrain them. The model fixes the ratio of the greatest to the least admissible distance and leaves the scale open, and so the bound of 6.2 × 10-28 per root hertz is a worked case and not a measurement.
For the Jupiter-shadow cities the result bears on the design of listening stations, since the same relations give the floor needed to hear a tone of given power at a given distance. The open methodological question is how a minimum distance can be estimated from an absence of technosignatures when a concealing civilisation has every reason to leave none, and the next calculation, one step toward a description of what any listener in the neighbourhood must have owned, is the dependence of the bound on a beamed antenna.
References
- Dlamini-Reyes, C. (57 DE). Strain at range from a periodic gravitational-wave emitter and the recovery of a steady tone. Journal of Gravitational-Wave Operations, Fleet International, 18, 31–62.
- Maruyama-Osei, T. (49 DE). Detection thresholds for steady tones of known frequency in stationary noise. Proceedings of Applied Speculative Statistics, pp. 88–109.
- Ketteridge, L. (7 BkE). A chronology of the Broadcast Era from Fleet and PDC logs. Bulletin of Post-Deterrence Historical Studies, 4, 15–44.
- Halvorsen-Adeyemi, P. (7 BkE). The scope of the cosmic-sociology axioms and the Lurker framework. Journal of Terminal Cosmology, 2, 40–68.
- Orlova-Banda, V. (8 BkE). The listening posture of a concealed civilisation. Journal of Cosmic Sociology, 21, 40–71.
- Pieterse-Lund, A. (8 BkE). Delay of a gravitational-wave front crossing a lowered-speed region. Journal of Dimensional Physics, 14, 120–141.
Open in Uncited Press →